III. Selection of assessment type
C. Formative or summative?
Assessments in medical education are important for more than just assigning grades, as they shape a student's learning journey. Formative and summative assessments are two critical types of assessments in this field. Striking a balance between these two types of assessments and understanding their dynamics is crucial for educators aiming for excellence in medical education.
BASIC Information
In medical education, evaluations are not solely for assigning grades. They play a pivotal role in shaping a student's learning journey. Two critical forms of assessment are formative and summative.
VIDEO
Formative & Summative AssessmentFormative Assessment: This is ongoing feedback provided to students during their learning. It’s like a health check-up for understanding, helping identify areas of strength and weakness.
Example: After a lesson on reading electrocardiograms (ECGs), a PA student might take a quick quiz or engage in a group discussion. This immediate feedback helps them realize if they've grasped the essential concepts.
VIDEO
Formative Assessment ExamplesVIDEO
Summative Assessment: Overview & ExamplesREAD
Formative vs. Summative AssessmentINTERMEDIATE Information
In a field as dynamic and critical as medicine, the right assessment approach can make a significant difference in a student's career trajectory.
READ
Managing tensions in assessment: moving beyondeither–or thinkingImmediate Feedback: It offers students a chance to understand and rectify mistakes as they learn.
Example: During clinical rotations, after interacting with a patient, a student might receive feedback from their supervising physician about their bedside manner or diagnostic reasoning.
Motivation and Engagement: Regular feedback can motivate students and keep them engaged in their learning journey.
Flexible and Adaptive: Formative assessment can be informal, like a discussion, or more structured, like a mini-test. It can adapt to the needs of the students and the teaching environment.
VIDEO
Formative online assessment in medicineValidation of Learning: Summative assessments certify that a student has achieved the requisite competencies to move forward in their education or profession.
Example: Before graduating, a PA student might have to pass a comprehensive exam, ensuring they possess the broad knowledge and skills necessary for their role.
Structured and Standardized: Summative assessments are typically more structured, ensuring a consistent evaluation framework. This makes them valuable for high-stakes decisions like certifications.
Long-Term Feedback: Results from summative assessments can guide future curriculum adjustments or highlight areas where broader student groups might be struggling.
VIDEO
What Are Formative and Summative Assessments?ADVANCED Information
For educators aiming for excellence, striking a balance between formative and summative assessments while understanding their intricate dynamics is key.
VIDEO
Advancing Healthcare Quality Through Formative and Summative AssessmentContinuous Monitoring: Use tools like digital portfolios, where students can document their learning journey, making it easier for educators to provide feedback.
Example: A student might upload a video of themselves performing a respiratory examination, allowing faculty to provide nuanced feedback on their technique.
Peer Feedback: Encourage peer evaluations. They can provide a different perspective, and the act of evaluating others reinforces learning.
Example: During clinical skills sessions, students can critique each other’s patient history-taking techniques.
Self-Assessment: Cultivate a culture of reflection. Encourage students to self-assess, promoting lifelong learning.
READ
Summative and Formative Assessment in Medicine: The Experience of an Anaesthesia TraineeObjective Structured Clinical Examinations (OSCEs): A gold standard in medical evaluation, OSCEs offer a robust summative assessment method, testing both theoretical knowledge and practical skills.
Example: A student might rotate through stations, each simulating different medical scenarios, from suturing a wound to managing an acute myocardial infarction.
Combining Multiple Assessment Methods: To get a holistic view of a student's competence, combine written exams, practical tests, and viva voce.
Feedback, Even in Summation: While summative assessments culminate learning periods, providing feedback is invaluable. It gives students insights into their performance, aiding future learning.